By Jordan E. Rosenfeld
I wrote fiction for the better part of 15 years before I finally realized what a scene really was. This is not to say that I had never written a scene—I’d written hundreds, possibly thousands of them, just without calling them by name or looking at their parts. I was, as many writers are, an intuitive writer—I grew up reading voraciously and taught myself to write by doing so. As I tell in the foreword to my writing book Make A Scene, it took a vivacious dance teacher, of all things, to teach me to hold my scenes up under a new lens and really look at their parts. The moment I began to do this, my fiction writing transformed.
Among my editing clients I find many writers like me—they bang out cumbersome scenes, or make notes to themselves in place of real scenes (“telling”) not because they lack talent, but they haven’t had the opportunity to see the parts of a scene clearly and therefore might over-burden it with setting details or fail to provide enough intelligent, plot-worthy action.
Scenes are, quite simply, the essential building blocks of great stories and novels—the cells of a body, if you will. If you can learn to write effective, vivid scenes, then your work as a writer actually becomes easier. A novel or story absolutely can be written scene by scene. When you focus on the container of the scene, you write more carefully and are forced to consider all the important elements, from setting details to action. And if you’re one of those writers who needs to run wild in your first draft, then you’ll be glad to know you can revise a rough draft into scenes, too. Learning to write great, competent scenes is the key to powerful story making.
Of all the ingredients of a good scene, however, there’s one that, without it, you really don’t have anything to show for yourself: Action. Why? Because when events happen in a semblance of real time in your pages, the reader is pulled headlong into your story. If, for paragraphs or pages, all you’ve written are lyrical sentences describing the color of the sky, a character’s beauty, and the halcyon days of her childhood, you can bet that you’ll have an impatient reader on your hands. Actually, the reader will be off your hands—because she’ll have gone on to find something that plugs her in and energizes her.
So keep in mind these key points about action in your scenes:
• Actions can be big or small, from car crashes to a slap on the cheek, but they must be there in every scene, and preferably involve your protagonist, or antagonist.
• Actions happen in “real time.” The reader must experience the actions as taking place “now.”
For more, consider taking one of my fiction writing workshops here through Editor Unleashed, or pick up my book Make A Scene: Crafting a Powerful Story One Scene at a Time.


{ 7 comments… read them below or add one }
Very helpful post, Jordan. Thanks for sharing!
Thanks, Cheryl. Hope we’ll see you in a workshop!
Jordan
Hi Jordan,
Very well written post.
And it’s something I’ve struggled with for a long time. Like you, I’m an intuitive writer and your analogy has provided some food for thought.
Even though I generally write non-fiction, it still must have depth to it or the reader is lost.
~ Annie
What starts and ends a scene? I mean, where does one scene end and another begin?
Hi Cheryl,
Thanks for your post and the lesson.
I’ve always considered writing short stories a good practice for writing a novel-length story because chapters in such a story have many things in common with their stand-alone short story cousins. Not everybody agrees, but that’s my take.
So will you be giving dance lessons along with scene writing lessons in your workshop? :-)
–John
This is just as important for nonfiction writers, especially those, like myself, who were once journalists — I find the reporter training about quoting accurately and verifying everything to be somewhat of a hindrance when taking the leap to creating scenes in creative nonfiction which vivify real events but which cannot always be 100 percent historically accurate.
And yes, I think you can also lay out a structure for a nonfiction piece in scenes as well. I find it helps to think visually – how would this be shown on a screen?
Doug: A scene can begin in any number of ways, with a quick setting description, even dialogue, but my touchstone is that it should begin with some kind of action–something curious and interesting that will make a reader say “wow, what’s going on here?”
Annie and Lisa–thanks for your thoughts.
John: I’m afraid I can’t dance well enough to teach anyone there :)